Showing posts with label Expenses. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Expenses. Show all posts

Thursday, October 29, 2009

Time to move on indeed

I listened to Tony McNulty try to explain himself at lunchtime. He convinced himself, although not me. Apparently he did everything within the rules, the investigating committee changed the rules, he was happy to comply with the committee's wish that he should pay the money back, he was sorry for whatever it was he should be sorry about, now was the time to "move on".
I don't think my jaw was the only one to drop to the floor. Our present crop of politicians are oblivious to embarrassment and impervious to shame. And even more incredible, we are being subjected to arguments that if we don't offer good pay and perks to prospective MPs we will not attract the best candidates for the job! Words fail me! They really do! McNulty, let us remember, was a minister, presumably one of the best and brightest the current system can offer the voting public. And what does he represent? A certain skill in presenting himself to the Westminster media and an unshakeable belief that everything his party thinks up and does, however misconceived and benighted, is good for us.
It is time to move on - to a new parliament and a new government.

Tuesday, October 13, 2009

Pay up AND resign

This would be my message to MPs who have abused and fiddled the system. The present (frankly unbelievable) outcry that the "rules" have now been changed by Sir Thomas Legg and that it's "unfair" to MPs just won't wash. I am fed up with them, and I suspect that I am one of millions. This is by far the worst, sleaziest, self-serving bunch of MPs in my memory. Don't forget we still have serving ministers who have fiddled their expenses and an Attorney-General who has broken the law and several Lords who have manipulated legislation for quite substantial under-the-table payments.
I refuse to listen to any more whining. Pay back what you have filched from the taxpayer, then resign! That's my message to all MPs.  And if they think they can get away with it by fillibustering until the next election I say go after them, just as HMRC resolutely pursues taxpayers who default. Give them no peace until they pay the money back. I hope then that this will be the last we hear of any of them

Monday, October 12, 2009

Calling MPs to account

I just flew in from Amman this afternoon to discover headlines about MP's expenses. The committee that Gordon Brown has hurriedly set up has apparently called it as it is rather than find ways of excusing MPs. No further honours for Sir Thomas Legge then.
What is astonsihing about today's story is that Labour MPs are going around complaining that they are not being treated fairly! Because they did everything within the so-called rules that they happily manipulated and are now being judged by a proper standard the word is that they now feel affronted.
Expect some protests that everything they claimed was in good faith!

Tuesday, September 22, 2009

Scotland is free!

Apparently Baroness Scotland did not hire an illegal immigrant; she merely forgot to make a photocopy of the woman's papers and for this "administrative error" she has been fined a whopping £5.000, which of course she can afford to pay, having squirreled away £170,000 in dubious expense claims.
The spinners are at it again! The original crime was to hire an illegal immigrant, a practice that Baroness Scotland herself deplored and tabled legislation to punish the practice, but it now appears that this was not a problem. The real crime was the mistake of failing to take and keep photocopies of the immigrant's documents.
What is it about Gordon Brown that he fails to understand the situation. Baroness Scotland may well be  marvellous person with many good qualities, but she is Attorney General. She administers the law and must be seen to respect it. If she fiddles the law to suit her own personal circumstances she must go. And that't that!
Tony Blair sacked Mandleson the first time around because he had made a mis-statement on his mortgage application. It was not a particularly big deal and no doubt Mandleson, or one of his backers, was good for the money. But Blair made him go because of the propriety of it. Why can't Brown understand this?

Tuesday, July 28, 2009

No surprise

Guido reports today that MPs have surreptitiously increase their subsistence allowance from £400 a month to £500. As before no receipts are required. Expect then to see reports next year of increased allowances for MPs. Obviously they don't care about public opinion. Obviously they don't need to care about public opinion because the electoral machinery of our so-called democracy has been stitched up to keep out potential renegades.
The lesson that might be learned from Ian Gibson's defenestration is that what really doesn't pay is to question the policies of party leadership.

Saturday, June 20, 2009

The X Files

When I bought my Daily Telegraph today the boy behind the counter read the banner "The Complete Expenses Files. Is that like the X-Files?"
"Yes", I said, so quick I even surprised myself, "the aliens are ripping us off."
He looked at me blankly, but at least I got my own joke.

Sunday, June 14, 2009

Practicing what you preach

I see from the Sunday Times today that Neil and Glenys Kinnock are doing very well out of state handouts. Glenys Kinnock collects a teacher's pension, a Brussels pension worth £46,000 pa, will be entitled to a further £19,750 pa related to her service as an MEP. Gordon Brown has just handed her an income of £83,375 for this coming year and she will be entitled to a pension based upon that. And to crown this little perk (to coin a phrase) she will be able to trough for years to come on the basis of her Lords' membership.
Neil Kinnock receives pensions from his service as MP and EU Comissioner totalling £112,000 and is also a Lord with all the additional benefits that that entails.
The Sunday Times article goes on to detail what some might consider excessive use of allowances and expenses and their habit of running this tax-funded enterprise as a family business.
Should I draw some comfort from the fact that people who have spent a lifetime preaching the benefits of state welfare should be among its primary recipients?

Saturday, May 30, 2009

I meet an MP

Today I met Mark Hoban, my MP, who was out campaigning with one of our local councillors. My first impression is that he is intelligent, personable, probably hard-working and CLEAN. Nothing has emerged about any irregularities in his expense claims and it may be fair to assume that after this time there is nothing to worry about.
So I was very good; I didn't raise the issue of MP's expense claims. Instead we talked about the business climate and his work in committee on the Finance Bill. This latter surprised me a little because I assumed that had been done and dusted some time ago.
Anyway it is a little reassuring to know that there are some MPs out there who are trying to do their best without abusing the voters.

Saturday, May 23, 2009

Archbishop of Deep Space 9

Some people have a talent for being on the wrong side of every issue. Gordon Brown is one example and Rowan Williams another. The last time the Archbishop of Deep Space 9 came to earth he was advocating Sharia law in this country. Now he feels that the exposure of MPs should come to an end. This would be fine if we had achieved anything out of this. Ministers are still parroting the line that they have done nothing wrong and the PM continues to try to kick this issue into the long grass of a committee report. No appeasement! Reform!

Wednesday, May 20, 2009

Normal service resumed?

Gordon Brown was up to his usual wooden, unimaginative standard today. An election would cause Zimbabwe-like chaos and therefore could not be called. Labour MPs who broke the rules would be disciplined which the electorate have already interpreted as meaning nobody will be disciplined as the "rules" forgave any excess. As if to reinforce that message Hazel Blears chirped up todat that she had done everything within the rules.
Brown has set up some committee which will presumably take months to report. Is this enough? Are we back to normal service? Will he get away with it?
Fortunately the Telegraph has more ammunition. Let's see what happens tomorrow.

Sunday, May 17, 2009

A winning goal for the Dead Tree Press

When The Daily Telegraph published its spoiler articles about Guido after he revealed the Damien McBride smear I vowed never to buy the newspaper again. I suppose that shows you should never say "never"! I am now on my tenth consecutive day of Telegraph purchases - a paper I have only occasionally bought before. Plainly the arrival of Benedict Brogan has provided some leadership and direction to the paper's political reporting. I'm not holding my breath, but I would expect to see Brogan and Heather Brooke in the next honours list.
Newspapers as businesses are clearly in some trouble and possibly in decline but the Telegraph has proved that there is life in the beast and that they have the resources and expertise to do a big story in depth. No other medium can match it for immediacy and in-depth analysis.
The newspaper is a well-known technology, like the book, and although I have listened to predictions of the demise of the book since 1993, it has not happened. in fact there are more books published than ever before. We should therefore reflect that the newspaper may find ways of surviving. It can be read at the breakfast table, in bed, in the bath, on the train, in a bus shelter, and in bright sunlight. It can be folded, crumpled, torn and ultimately disposed of. It is often re-cycled - used to wrap fish and chips, insulate the chests of Tour de France riders making a rapid mountain descent, absorb spillage, provide temporary protection of surfaces and is even used as wall insulation. When I once bought a lakeside cabin in Canada many years ago I found old 1930s newspapers in the walls when eventually came to remodel it.
So I revising my opinion about the potential life of newspapers. There is a shift to online media but don;t write off newspapers - not just yet.

Friday, May 15, 2009

A custard pie for Big Brother

George Orwell's 1984 had a context; he was writing it in post-war Britain where the tendency to, and consequences of, totalitarian control were obvious to most people. In a very different genre J R R Tolkein developed a similar theme.
The society I in which I grew up in the 40s and 50s was very tightly controlled but held together as much by social convention as government regulation, although there was plenty of that. We had food rationing, restricted shop hours, no sport on Sunday, restricted pub opening times and the BBC controlled the airwaves. For a number of years there wasn't much grumbling - "mustn't complain" was the guiding principle, but things began to open up in the 1960s and for someone of my generation this was the right reaction against the stifling environment we had inherited. It took a generation to move away from that monolithic society but it did happen.
Nobody wants to go willingly back to those days but it does now appear that government does want to return to the days where almost everybody did what they were told. We have had a decade or more of increasingly prescriptive and regulatory government spending millions (no billions) on wild technology schemes that they imagine will bring us all under control. Ironically every one of these schemes has failed to achieve its objective and has turned ordinary citizens into an anarchic frame of mind.
So John Redwood, who has remained wisely silent during the expenses disclosures, is right to make this observation:
I have often written about how much many people hate the bossy, autocratic snooper government which has damaged our freedoms in the last decade. We hate the cameras, the road blocks, the hectoring public advertisements, the multiplying army of regulators, the aggressive tax collectors, the enforced political correctness, the thought police, the concrete blocks around Parliament, the spying on our rubbish bins and the stealthy approach to making us all have Identity cards. Government, both national and local, has become a bunch of snoopers who know how we should all live and know where we live.
The Big Brother state always fails. There are dozens of examples in our recent history. Eventually people tire of it and rebel and I think, along with John Redwood, that this is fueling the anger and resentment against the MPs. At the moment the public are in a mildly anarchic mood - a custard pie in the face perhaps - but unless the government shows itself capable of reforming Parliament, the mood could degenerate into something worse.

Food-raid

Memories of  the 19th century famine in Ireland run deep,and Tony Blair was big enough to apologise for that - on behalf of whom I am not sure. When my great great great grandfather was born in Donegal in 1780 there was an estimated population of 8 million; by the end of the 18th century the population was half that and has never recovered. The famine was a terrible period.
It is therefore heart-warming to know that our goverment has taken steps to ensure that this does not happen again and that Mr and Mrs Robinson, elected MPs from Northern Ireland, are the first beneficiaries of our new food-(r)aid program. Apparently they were able to claim £400 each, £800 per month in total, to cover their food bill. God be praised! Our Irish cousins will never starve again!

The Dredge Report

I don't have a moat; you don't have a moat. You might have thought that moats belonged to the days of yore when knights of Appledore did their deeds of derring-do. Not so it appears. Some MPs have moats and they need cleaning. Naturally this sort of expense should be charged to the taxpayer. How else is a hard-working MP to get a good night's sleep unless he is assured that the burden of moat-cleaning is undertaken by the allowance system? It is reassuring to know is it not that the Fees Office has been so understanding.
But perhaps our MPs are not being so archaic after all. The way the economy of this country is going and the absence of government my mean that we will all need moats in future. Just to be prepared you might wish to clip the article on moat cleaning from today's Daily Telegraph - page 27.

Heckling Time

I missed Question Time last night but picked it up on iPlayer this morning. I've heard ironic laughter and murmers of discontent on previous programs when politicians have tried to defend the indefensible but never this level of hostility. Poor old Ming Campbell, whom most of us in sober moments would regard as an honourable politician, got caught up in this too. And Margaret Beckett! Well!
I suppose she got where she did by arguing that black is white and defending her position at all costs and after years of practice she knows no other way. Even this morning she was on the radio again telling voters that they did not understand.
The point is, however, that we understand only too well the venality of this system and the quality of the people who have put themselves forward to represent our interests. 

Thursday, May 14, 2009

From Profumo to Blears: a tale of shabby behaviour.

I remember the Profumo Affair, as it came to be known. The salacious part was the sexual hi-jinks of the Cliveden set - "how the other half loves" as the wags of the day might have put it. The political part was that call girls were being shared between Russian diplomats and Cabinet Ministers. The stupid part was Profumo lying to MacMillan about his involvement in an attempt to cover up.
There are not too many comparisons with today's parliamentary scandal but I do want to note that Profumo left office and parliament in absolute disgrace and then after a lifetime's penance doing unheralded charity work eventually redeemed himself.
In the end he proved a better example than today's crop of MPs who appear to believe that brandishing a cheque in a broadcast studio is their quick channel to redemption,



Poachers and Gamekeepers

We often make the comparison between poachers (outside the law) and gamekeepers (upholding the law), most often these days when someone from the wrong side of the law takes on the gamekeeper role. Until today I hadn't considered that you could simultaneously be a poacher and a gamekeeper. Consider the case of Don Touhig, whom I, in common with most of the country, had not heard of until yesterday. He is the chairman of the Members Allowance Committee which Gordon Brown has assured us will bring about a radical shake up of the system.
Oh yeah? Mr Touhig has been, and as far as we know remains, a vigorous opponent of change and transparency and a keen ally of the Speaker. He was in the vanguard of resistance to exposure of any of these receipts in the first instance and had the High Court not disagreed would have been successful in keeping the lid on this can of worms.
Mr Touhig has also been a "flipper" and has no doubt benefited from the egregious system he is dedicated to maintain - proof, if any were needed, that you can be both a poacher and a gamekeeper at the same time.

Wednesday, May 13, 2009

A Special Relationship

The term "special relationship" used to be reserved for the diplomatic ties between this country and the USA - Churchill and Rooseveldt, MacMillan and Kennedy, Thatcher and Reagan, Blair and Bush and even Gordon Brown's pathetic attempts to tie himself to Barack Obama's coat tails - but now we learn that our MPs (all 646 of them) have a special relationship with HMRC. I am no longer astonished.
So that probably means, as Hazel Blears has already told us, that she has done nothing wrong by declaring one of her homes as a "second home" for House of Commons allowance purposes and as a primary residence for Capital Gains allowance. Apparently they fill in a special tax form far different from the one that mere mortals like ourselves have to complete. They don't pay tax on their expenses claim, unlike the rest of us whose expenses are subject to some rigorous analysis. 
I haven't tried to do this, but I strongly suspect that HMRC would not allow me to designate a holiday cottage in Devon as my principal residence if I were to sell it, thus avoiding the Capital gains tax that Hazel Blears happily voted for, knowing that she would never be called upon to pay it herself.

Oops!

So now Elliot Morley has been found out claiming his mortgage interest long after he had sold the property. Carry on claiming! It was a "mistake" and apparently has been paid back "within the last two weeks", which I interpret to mean as soon as the news was out that the Daily Telegraph had the goods on MPs. Funny that - all this time he never noticed the oversight and yet the minute he knew that the information was in the public domain it became immediately plain to him.

Stephen Fry and Lembit Opik

Until yesterday Stephen Fry was on his way to National Treasure status, then as he was doorstepped by a reporter on the way to an award ceremony he decided to give us all a lecture about how we were all being petit bourgeois about the abuse of expenses and should grow up and realize that there are far more important issues to concern ourselves with.
Yes there are important issues but none is more important in my view than how we are governed. We have an quaint system of government based upon a few written documents and historical tradition and this lack of definition means that there has to be a strong bond of trust between the governors and the governed. If that is broken (and it has been) how can we have any confidence that the big issues like the economy and efficient delivery of public services?

I have always seen Lembit Opik as a slightly weird but engaging eccentric. Good on UFOs, Weather Women and Cheeky Girls and good for a chuckle on "Have I got News for You". Oh well, today on Simon Mayo's show he came across as humourless and self-regarding as he tried to defend the right of MPs to keep this information secret.